Writing a PIP Mandatory Reconsideration Letter: A Guide for Carers in Bournemouth and Poole

If someone you care for has received a PIP decision that does not reflect how their condition genuinely affects their daily life, you have every right to challenge it. As their carer, you often have a more complete and more honest picture of how they function day to day than any assessor who spent 45 minutes with them could obtain. That knowledge is exactly what a well-written mandatory reconsideration letter can put in front of the DWP.

This guide is written specifically for carers in the Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole area who are supporting someone through a PIP challenge. It explains what a mandatory reconsideration is, what the DWP is required to consider, how to write the letter when you are the one doing it on someone else’s behalf, what to include, and where to get help locally if you need it.

What a Mandatory Reconsideration Is

A mandatory reconsideration (MR) is a formal request to the DWP asking them to look again at a PIP decision. It is the first stage of challenging any PIP award that you believe is wrong, whether that is a refusal, an award at a lower rate than expected, or a reduction following a review. Before an appeal can go to the independent tribunal, a mandatory reconsideration must be requested first.

According to DWP’s own research published in March 2026, many claimants and their carers find the mandatory reconsideration stage confusing and do not understand what they need to include to give the request the best chance of success. The research also confirms that carers play a significant and often underrecognised role in helping people navigate the challenge process, and that having a carer’s detailed first-hand account of daily difficulties can be valuable evidence for the DWP to consider.

The success rate at the MR stage is around 22 percent, which means most successful challenges happen at the tribunal stage that follows. But completing the MR properly matters for two reasons. First, it gives you the best realistic chance of resolution before tribunal. Second, the letter you write at MR stage becomes part of the evidence bundle that goes to the tribunal if the MR is unsuccessful. A well-written MR letter strengthens every stage that follows.

Your Role as a Carer in the PIP Process

As an unpaid carer, you can play a formal role in the PIP challenge process. Specifically, you can:

• Write the mandatory reconsideration letter on behalf of the person you care for, with their consent

• Provide a supporting letter or statement describing what you observe in their daily life

• Accompany the person to any tribunal hearing and give evidence about their needs

• Act as an appointee if the person lacks capacity to manage their own affairs, in which case you act on their behalf rather than alongside them

The most important thing to establish before you write is whether you have the person’s consent and in what capacity you are acting. If they have capacity, they should ideally sign or co-author the letter. If you are writing on their behalf because they are unable to do so themselves, note this at the start of the letter and explain why.

Your own first-hand observations as a carer are also highly valuable as a separate piece of evidence. The DWP is required to consider all the evidence submitted with an MR request. A clear, specific statement from you describing what you observe when you help the person with daily tasks can address gaps or inaccuracies in the original assessment report that the person themselves may not have been able to articulate under the pressure of the assessment.

Before You Write: What to Get Hold Of

Do not start writing until you have the following documents:

• The PIP decision letter, which states the score awarded for each activity and the reasons for the decision

• The healthcare professional’s assessment report, which the DWP used to make the decision. Request this from the DWP in writing if you do not already have it. They must provide it.

• Any medical letters, consultant reports or GP correspondence that are relevant to the person’s condition

• Notes or a diary of what the person can and cannot do on typical days, including worse days

• Your own observations as a carer of specific tasks you help with, including how often, how long it takes and what happens when they try to manage without help

Read the assessment report carefully alongside the decision letter. Note every point where the assessor’s description does not match reality. These are the specific grounds you will address in the MR letter.

The Deadline: Do Not Miss It

The mandatory reconsideration request must reach the DWP within one month of the date on the PIP decision letter. If you miss this deadline, you can still apply up to 13 months from the decision date if you have a good reason for the delay, such as illness, bereavement or a period of crisis. Always explain the reason for any late request. The address to send the letter to is on the PIP decision letter itself.

Send the letter by recorded post and keep the proof of postage. Do not rely on a phone call. The DWP may tell you they have noted the MR request verbally, but a phone request provides far less protection than a dated written submission if there is any later dispute about whether the request was made in time.

How to Structure the MR Letter When Writing as a Carer

Opening: Who You Are and Your Authority to Write

Begin by identifying yourself and your relationship to the claimant. State clearly that you are writing on their behalf and that they have given their consent, or explain why you are writing in their stead.

I am writing on behalf of [full name of claimant], date of birth [date], National Insurance number [number]. I am their [relationship: daughter / partner / friend and primary carer]. [Name] has asked me to write this letter on their behalf because [briefly state the reason if relevant: they find written communication very difficult due to their condition / their mental health makes engaging with formal processes extremely distressing / they have given me authority to manage their DWP correspondence].

Statement of What You Challenge and Why

State clearly that you are requesting a mandatory reconsideration of the PIP decision dated [date] and briefly identify the activities where you believe the scoring is wrong.

I am requesting a mandatory reconsideration of the PIP decision dated [date], which awarded [name] [X] points for daily living and [X] points for mobility. I believe the decision does not accurately reflect [name]’s ability to carry out the following activities: [list the activities where the score is disputed].

Activity by Activity: Your Evidence as a Carer

This is the heart of the letter. Work through each disputed activity in a separate numbered section. For each one, state what score was awarded, what score you believe is correct and why. Use specific examples from your own observations. The more concrete and date-referenced your examples are, the harder they are to dismiss.

Activity 1: Preparing food – awarded 0 points, should be 4 points (descriptor d: needs assistance to prepare or cook a simple meal)

I assist [name] with preparing food on [frequency: six out of seven days / every day without exception]. On days when I am not present, [name] does not cook. They eat whatever does not require preparation: cold food, pre-packaged items, or they do not eat at all. The reason is [describe specifically: the pain in their hands makes using a knife or holding a pan unsafe / their cognitive difficulties mean they cannot follow the steps of a recipe without losing track and leaving the hob unattended / their fatigue means that standing at a worktop for more than three or four minutes results in them needing to sit or lie down immediately]. I have witnessed [specific incident: them dropping a pan of boiling water on [approximate date] / them leaving the hob on and not noticing / them unable to open a tin without my help]. The assessment report states they can prepare a simple meal independently. This does not reflect what I observe.

Addressing Inaccuracies in the Assessment Report

If the assessment report contains statements about the person that are factually wrong, challenge each one directly. Quote the inaccuracy from the report, then explain the accurate position from your own first-hand experience.

The assessment report states that [name] ‘walks with a normal gait and showed no signs of discomfort.’ I was present at this assessment. [Name] did show signs of discomfort. They told the assessor on two occasions that they were in pain, but this was not recorded. They also walked from the car park to the assessment room using their walking aid and required a ten-minute rest on arrival. This was not reflected in the report.

Your Carer’s Statement

If the person is writing the letter themselves, you can include your observations as a separate statement attached to their letter. If you are writing the whole letter on their behalf, weave your observations throughout. Either way, make clear that you are the person who sees them daily and that your account is based on direct, regular observation rather than inference.

Closing: What You Are Asking For

Close clearly. State the outcome you want: a revised decision awarding the correct points for each activity you have challenged.

I am asking the DWP to reconsider the PIP decision dated [date] and to award [name] the following points: [list the activities and the descriptor you believe applies to each]. I am available to provide further information and am happy for the DWP to contact me directly if that would assist. Please respond in writing to [your address / name’s address].

Full Worked Example MR Letter Written by a Carer

[Carer’s full name]

[Carer’s address]

[Date]

PIP Mandatory Reconsideration

[Address from the decision letter]

Re: Mandatory Reconsideration Request for [Claimant’s full name], DOB [date], NINO [number]

Dear Sir or Madam,

I am writing to request a mandatory reconsideration of the PIP decision dated [date] on behalf of [name], for whom I am the primary unpaid carer. [Name] has asked me to write this letter because [state reason]. I have their consent to do so.

I have read the decision letter and the healthcare professional’s assessment report. I believe the decision does not reflect [name]’s actual day-to-day functioning. As someone who assists [name] with [daily personal care / cooking / mobility / medication / all daily tasks] on [frequency], I am in a position to describe their needs accurately and in detail.

Activity 2: Taking nutrition

Awarded: 0 points. I believe the correct score is 2 points (descriptor b: needs prompting to be able to take nutrition).

[Name] does not independently initiate eating or drinking during the day without prompting. On days when I am not present, they have gone without eating until late afternoon or evening. This is not a preference. It is a direct consequence of [their depression affecting motivation / their cognitive difficulties meaning they do not register hunger / their pain meaning that the act of preparing even a simple drink feels prohibitive]. I prompt them to eat and drink [number] times per day on the majority of days. The assessment report does not mention this difficulty.

Activity 4: Washing and bathing

Awarded: 0 points. I believe the correct score is 3 points (descriptor d: needs assistance to wash their body).

I assist [name] with bathing or showering on [frequency]. They cannot safely step in and out of the bath without support due to [describe reason: balance problems / pain / weakness in their legs]. We have [a bath board / grab rails / a shower chair] but even with these aids, [name] requires my physical assistance to get in and out safely. I was not present at the assessment and the assessor did not ask about aids used. The report states [name] can wash independently, which is only accurate on the rare occasions when I am with them throughout.

[Continue for each disputed activity in the same format]

Inaccuracy in the assessment report

The report states that [name] ‘managed the short walk from the waiting room without difficulty.’ I accompanied [name] to the assessment on [date]. The walk from the car to the building took [X minutes]. [Name] stopped twice. They told the assessor they were in pain when they arrived but this was not noted. I would ask that the DWP takes this account into consideration alongside the written report.

Request

I am asking the DWP to reconsider [name]’s PIP award and to award points in accordance with the descriptors I have identified above. I attach [list evidence: a letter from [name]’s GP dated [date] / a copy of [name]’s occupational therapy report / a care diary I have kept for the past four weeks]. Please acknowledge this request and confirm the outcome in writing.

Yours sincerely,

[Your name]

[Your relationship to the claimant]

[Your contact details]

[Claimant’s signature if possible]

What Happens After You Submit

Once the DWP receives your MR request, a different decision maker reviews the original decision and the new information you have submitted. They should issue the MR outcome letter within two to eight weeks, though in practice it can take longer. As Citizens Advice confirms, around 22 percent of MRs result in a changed decision. If the MR is unsuccessful, you receive a Mandatory Reconsideration Notice, which is what you need to submit an appeal to the independent tribunal. Keep this notice safe. You cannot appeal without it.

Do not be discouraged by an unsuccessful MR. The tribunal stage, which follows, is where the majority of successful challenges happen. Over 60 percent of PIP appeals heard at tribunal are decided in the claimant’s favour. The letter you have written for the MR forms the foundation of that appeal.

Help Writing a PIP MR Letter in Bournemouth and Poole

Writing a mandatory reconsideration letter when you are already stretched as a carer is one of the most demanding things you can be asked to do. You are trying to describe someone else’s experience in precise, evidenced language, challenge an official report, and do all of this under a time deadline, while also managing the daily reality of caring.

LetterLab is based in Poole and works with carers across the BCP area on exactly this kind of letter. Whether you are writing the MR yourself or want help putting your observations into a supporting statement that strengthens the case, get in touch.

LetterLab, Unit 157185, PO Box 7169, Poole, BH15 9EL

Visit LetterLab or contact us directly. We are currently offering a small number of free letters in exchange for an honest review, which may include PIP MR letters for carers in the BCP area.

Free Local Support for Carers in BCP

If you are a carer in Bournemouth, Christchurch or Poole and need advice on the PIP process, the following local and national services can help:

• BCP Carer Support: free information and support for unpaid carers across the BCP area, accessible via BCP Council’s website

• Citizens Advice Bournemouth and Poole: free welfare benefits advice including PIP challenges and MR support

• Age UK Bournemouth, Poole and East Dorset: support for older carers navigating the benefits system

• Carers UK helpline: 0808 808 7777, Monday to Friday

Frequently Asked Questions: PIP MR Letters for Carers in BCP

Can I write a PIP mandatory reconsideration letter on behalf of the person I care for in Bournemouth or Poole?

Yes. If the person you care for has given their consent, you can write the MR letter on their behalf. Include a statement at the start explaining your role and that you have their consent. If they have capacity, their signature on the letter strengthens it further.

What should I include in a PIP MR letter as a carer?

Include your name and your relationship to the claimant, a challenge to each specific activity where the score is wrong, your first-hand observations of what you assist them with and how often, any inaccuracies in the assessment report that you noticed, and any supporting evidence such as GP letters or your own written care diary.

How long do I have to request a PIP mandatory reconsideration?

You have one month from the date on the PIP decision letter. If you miss this, you can still apply up to 13 months later if you have a good reason, such as illness or a caring emergency. Always explain the delay in your letter.

What if the MR is unsuccessful?

You will receive a Mandatory Reconsideration Notice. Keep it. You then have one month to appeal to the independent Social Security and Child Support Tribunal. Over 60 percent of PIP tribunal hearings are decided in the claimant’s favour. The carer can attend the tribunal and give evidence about the person’s needs.

Is there local help in Bournemouth or Poole with PIP mandatory reconsideration letters?

Yes. Citizens Advice Bournemouth and Poole provides free benefits advice including help with PIP MR letters. BCP Carer Support can also signpost you to appropriate help. LetterLab, based in Poole, helps carers write formal letters to the DWP including PIP mandatory reconsideration submissions.

The Key Takeaway: Your Observations Matter More Than You Think

The healthcare professional who assessed the person you care for spent a short time with them in an unfamiliar setting. You see the reality of their daily life, often multiple times a day, on both good and difficult days. Your first-hand account is not supplementary evidence. In many cases it is the most important evidence available.

Write it clearly. Make it specific. Address each activity the assessment got wrong. Reference what you personally observe rather than what you have been told. And do not stop at the MR if it is unsuccessful. The tribunal is where the majority of successful challenges happen, and the letter you write now is the foundation of everything that follows.

Get help writing to the DWP